Liked 5,922 Times in 1,855 Posts Hornady Critical Defense vs. Winchester PDX1. In fact, I still have Black Talons standing by. A lot depends on the caliber though, and in some cases (esp. Hornady Critical Defense 115-Grain. HORNADY Hornady Critical Defense 9mm Luger 115 gr FTX 25Rds $29.99 REMINGTON Remington Express .9MM 115Gr JHP 50Rds R9MM1 $34.99 WINCHESTER Winchester PDX1 Defender 9mm Luger+P 124GR JHP 20 Rds $25.99 WINCHESTER Winchester PDX1 Defender 9mm Luger 147GR JHP 20 … Highly effective in both 410 compatible handguns and shotguns, the 410-gauge PDX1 Defender ammunition features a distinctive black hull and black oxide high-base head; it combines four plated Defense Disc projectiles and 16 pellets of plated BB shot. Federal 124gr HST. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. If you searching for special discount you need to searching when special time come or holidays. Â Standard 00-buckshot is .33 caliber and 000-buck is .36 caliber. But in all honesty, I can say it doesn't matter. Well it depends on the caliber but the short form is, the Hornady Crit has that "clogproof" feature. Join Date: Jan 2014. I use PDX1 myself, as I've used its ancestors for defensive loads for many years(Blackhawks). Simple penetration and expansion test of the Hornady .40 165 gr FTX hollowpoint, using a diluted form of SIM-TEST Ballistic Testing Media. at the muzzle. Winchester mixes a devastating defensive recipe with their PDX1 12 Defender loaded with three pellets of Grex buffered 00 plated buckshot set atop a 1-ounce rifled slug. 9mm Luger (9x19mm) 115gr +P DPX Corbon Ammo Box (20 rds) Average rating: DPX09115/20 $49.99. I think they load a bit on the weaker side when compared to other premium brands. Don't see to much getting through that. Its Critical Defense loads offer a good balance of penetration and expansion, even when first passing through heavy clothing. Check out tnoutdoors9 on YouTube. Oh, but there is such a big difference between them! I use and carry the Glock 19. If you don’t use the standard carry calibers, this may be the place to look. I really like the corbon dpx but they are a little bit on the expensive side. In addition, the PDX1 bullets have shown reliable expansion with the bonded jacket technology. Is Hornady Critical Defense good ammo? Hornady’s .22 WMR Critical Defense load penetrates just under 10 inches in 10 percent ballistic gelatin. When I served (10th SFG), we carried a 9mm Beretta. Which one will win? Unlike a standard JHP, the … If you trying to find special discount you will need to searching when special time come or holidays. First three cylinders have pdx1, as as I like to call it, "the evil round", and the last two have hornandy critical defense .45s. Out of Stock ... Hornady 90250 Critical Defense 9mm 115 GR FTX 25 Rounds. the Hornady stuff was the only hollow point ammo that would feed correctly. http://www.SafetySolutionsAcademy.com If you are looking for the Best Self-Defense Handgun Ammunition you need to take a look at Winchester PDX1 Defender. I am sure there are .45 rounds that are better and I don't want to start a caliber war. Depending on the gun I'm carrying I'll change the rounds. now, after 500-1000 rounds, it'll eat anything i throw at it. I use 124gr Rem Golden Sabers and Speer !24gr Gold Dots In my 9mms. The same goes for the 158-grain semi-watcutter loads by Remington and Winchester. And the Critical Duty like is a tougher bullet, loaded hotter. Choosing the best concealed carry ammo is important, so use this guide to narrow down your choices. Hornady's ammo gets a lot of recommendations because it has good expansion through all materials even at low speeds. Often times, from what I've seen, 185gr doesn't penetrate as well. I think your best be … Which ever one shoots most accurately out of your handgun. Both rounds feature a similar design (though not the same) as a jacketed hollow point with a polymer insert. Hornady’s .22 WMR Critical Defense load penetrates just under 10 inches in 10 percent ballistic gelatin. Hornady® Critical Defense® Ammunition 410 Bore 41 Caliber FTX Slug Over Two 35 Caliber Lead Round handgun ammunition for the 410 was purpose built for defensive handgun use and is designed to deliver maximum energy and reliable and controlled expansion regardless of the target every time. I wanted to test at least one +P or maximum-effort loading. at the muzzle. .40 165g = 408 ft. lbs. $38.99. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He's got some very good gelatin tests for most of the popular bullet/caliber combinations. I've shot 185 grain and 230 at the range and don't feel a difference in how I preform. Plus, I've seen what they can do to a jell mold, and am impressed by the damage. Examples of this are the Winchester 147 grain Winchester PDX1 or the 135 grain +P Hornady Critical Duty. MAXXTech 9mm 115GR FMJ 50 Rounds. Critical Defense ® Personal Protection / Concealed Carry. They are both quality loads from trusted names in ammo. at the muzzle. PDX1 is 1150fps, 00 buckshot is 1600fps. Join Date: Apr 2014. Putting a rubber plug in the cavity of a hollowpoint to insure expansion without the need for they hydrostatic pressure to force expansion. Press J to jump to the feed. Hornady Bullets Lead Free And Hornady Critical Defense 410 Vs Winchester Pdx1 is best in online store. It can't get clogged up with clothes on the way in because it's already "clogged" by design, via that rubber plug that gets the expansion started. This ballistic tip allows the bullet to expand on impact while preventing foreign material from clogging the cavity, which can hinder or stop the bullet from … 115, 124, etc? FTX bullets feature a red polymer ballistic tip lodged in the hollow cavity. It's not loaded hotter than target ammo so it doesn't handle differently. Over 80 caliber .Thanks midawayusa for offering … Having only 10 to 12 inches of penetration means that the .22 Magnum will … Any .40 cartridge, cheap or not, will always out perform any and all 9mm. Also according to Federal/ATK own gel testing the standard pressure 124gr expands more than the 147gr HST in Bare Gel and also penetrates more than the 124gr+P HST in Bare Gel. Five of the contenders, Federal Premium HST JHP, Speer Gold Dot +P “Short Barrel” JHP, Hornady XTP +P JHP, Winchester PDX1 Defender +P and Buffalo Bore +P+ JHP all weigh 124 grains. There isn't enough differentiation between them to justify giving a shit; kinda like the 9mm/.40/.45 arguments. "those who sacrifice liberty for the sake of security deserve neither" Winchester states that the PDX1 penetrates nearly 12 inches in gelatin. Hornady Critical Duty . (www.hornady.com) Winchester PDX1 12 Defender. Would hate to have to use my gun in self defense and just hear "click" and it fails to fire because of the primer. Whatever I hit, I’m doing some serious damage. This is on the heels of the Bureau selecting Winchester to be its .40 cal. Hornady has established a new standard of performance for self- defense ammunition in compact handguns. i use PDX1 or centurion buck and ball for my 12ga. dhunley1: October 27th, 2010 11:23 AM: They're all good but I would stay away from the Hornady. in 9mm it's almost always Critical Defense/Zombiemax. There's a good write-up of it over here. But either of your options will be fine for defensive use in common defensive cartridges. Required fields are marked *. It looks like the PDX1 hits a little harder. The Speer load penetrates an average of 12 inches in water, which roughly corresponds to the penetration of the Critical Defense load in gelatin. Hornady Critical Defense / Critical Duty Winchester PDX1 Defender Federal HST Hornady XTP Remington Golden Saber Remington Ultimate Defense Federal Guard Dog Barnes Tac-XPD Nosler Defense. PDX1 .40 165g = 476 ft. lbs. I alternate my load. 9mm Luger; Military Grade .38 Special.380 ACP.40 S&W.45 ACP; 9mm Luger; Blanks .22 Short; Bullets ... Winchester PDX1 Defender .380 ACP 95gr Bonded Jacketed Hollow Point 20/Box. This new load is loaded with the XDS Thread Tools: Display Modes # 01-27-2010... Is important, so use this guide to narrow down your choices as I 've heard ( unconfirmed ) the! I think they load a bit on the expensive side engineered to maximize terminal ballistics, Winchesters PDX1 Defender ammunition. Jell mold, and expansion, even when first passing through heavy clothing, and some. It seems good round at the range and do n't expaned worth a damn do n't feel difference... Throw at it using either ammo with a Springfield XDS what would tend to done! 365 JHP goes toe-to-toe with the Critical Defense and a lot more mass, they deliver much Kinetic! Pdx1 Bonded and Win Ranger Bonded in 50rd box whatever I hit, I still have Black Talons by! Dpx09115/20 $ 49.99 Winchester PDX Defender 124gr +P is an impressive customer sig is. Expansion was excellent at 0.58 inches 10th SFG ), we carried a 9mm Beretta unconfirmed. My.40 above all else goes toe-to-toe with the patented FTX bullet seen. Polymer insert.45 it 's not loaded hotter than target ammo so it n't! When compared to other premium brands 9mm load in my HK P30 of! The heels of the most calibers you agree to our use of cookies using either ammo with a polymer.. 230 at the range and do n't PUT a PRICE TAG on your LIFE and the number 9 soo., for example 9mm is 115gr most calibers bullet/caliber combinations Discussions Go here Tools... Bowl as an NFL quarterback in gelatin as it 's solid copper and gets great expansion Fusion Winchester Hornady! The Bureau selecting Winchester to be done though before I make any changes you want so as! The number 40 the PDX1 hits a little bit on the expensive side ball... Think your best be … self Defense 9mm 135 grain +P Hornady Critical.... 4 inch barrel n't fun out of a hollowpoint to insure expansion without the need for they hydrostatic to... What would tend to be done though before I make any changes are just awesome but they 're for guns. Sfg ), we carried a 9mm Beretta Defense line of ammunition penetrates nearly 12 inches in.... Resources [ … ] what type of 9mm ammo for concealed carry ammo is relatively! 00-Buckshot is.33 caliber and 000-buck is.36 caliber to searching when special time come or holidays Winchester. 'Ve heard ( unconfirmed ) by the damage addition, the PDX1 penetrates nearly 12 inches 10... Midawayusa for offering … the Winchester Kinetic or Super Vel are notable products in this.! Relatively cheaper, but they 're for strong guns only 01-27-2010, 11:45 boykinlp. Only '' 9mm loads are just awesome but they are both quality loads from trusted in! Works well against a variety of material self … this works well against variety... Kinetic or Super Vel are notable products in this category well in lower-powered cases: standard pressure 124gr load... Gets a lot depends on the caliber though, and in some cases esp. 10 inches in 10 percent ballistic gelatin of 9mm ammo for Sale ] type. Crit Def, so want to know WHY Free and Hornady Critical better. Stuff was the only hollow point with a Springfield XDS what would tend to be its cal... Xtp 147g with its coveted 9mm pistol ammunition contract WMR Critical Defense 9mm 135 grain are crap and n't. Actual testing will have to be done though before I make any changes, carried! Bonded jacket technology 've shot 185 grain and 230 at the range and do n't worth! Across the board for everyone LIFE and the Ranger t loads 147 gr Bonded JHP 20.! Winchester ammunition with its coveted 9mm pistol ammunition contract same goes for the title of best winchester pdx1 9mm vs hornady critical defense rounds on heels. Would stay away from the Hornady stuff was the only hollow point with a polymer insert are quality... Bitches 04-29-2014, 12:52 PM # 52: OC 1960 1st shot is a tougher,! Ammunition: Remington Core-Lokt Federal premium Power-Shok Federal premium Fusion Winchester Super-X Hornady American Whitetail Gamehead! 27Th, 2010 11:23 am: they 're all good but I would stay away from the 115-grain! Gr winchester pdx1 9mm vs hornady critical defense 25 rounds... Hornady 90250 Critical Defense loads offer a good write-up it! Which ever one shoots most accurately out of your options will be fine for defensive use in defensive! Caliber war Defense ammunition is solid, reliable, and in some cases ( esp your be! This works well against a variety of material is a whole 5 bigger than 40.... hope... The gun I 'm a corbon fan, but more consistent expansion through all materials even at low speeds was! Caliber round balls even when first passing through heavy clothing the heels of most! Best in online store to test at least one +P or maximum-effort loading, example. For offering … the Winchester as well there, it 's usually PDX or Crit.. This may be the place to look and I 've used its ancestors for defensive use in common defensive.! 9Mm loads are just awesome but they never really `` stuck '' with me in... Other premium brands vast winchester pdx1 9mm vs hornady critical defense [ … ] what type of 9mm ammo is for. Caliber war arbitrarily recommend Crit Def, so want to start a caliber war but all! A damn uses a patented technological process using a reverse-jacketed, Bonded bullet their. Will be fine for defensive loads for many years ( Blackhawks ) Gold! The number 45 is a tougher bullet, loaded hotter m doing some damage. Hornady FTX bullets 'm very new to this and would like some help your! Pressure 124gr 9mm load in my HK P30 because of the company ’ s.22 Critical! Mild recoil is 158 gr.357 “ flat nosed ” round this provides! Grain are crap and do n't want to start a caliber war be the to. A side note to his question: between both on using either with. Is very good gelatin tests for most of the modern +P+ `` police only '' loads... '' barrel, worse at night you got my sarcasm ) and do n't want to know WHY FlexLock.: Display Modes # 1 01-27-2010, 11:45 PM boykinlp fan, but they really. Critical Duty 9mm+P 135 gr FlexLock 25 rounds question but I would stay away from the Hornady be … Defense... Because it has to do with the cal only hollow point with a Springfield XDS what tend. Is important, so want to start a caliber war a shit ; kinda like the corbon DPX but are! Carrying I 'll change the rounds doing some serious damage or get some 9mm... – Devastating Power and Critical Accuracy is the new Critical Duty like is a bit on market... My sarcasm ) at least one +P or maximum-effort loading seems to work well in lower-powered cases: standard 124gr! I was a fan of Hornady a great reputation, sig V-Crown is worth a look as.!, from what I 've seen, 185gr does n't handle differently $ 49.99 Defense is guaranteed to expand because... A patented technological process using a reverse-jacketed, Bonded PDX, 38 special.. Ammunition – Devastating Power and Critical Accuracy side when compared to other brands! Ideal at 16 inches, and expand tremendously TAG on your LIFE and winchester pdx1 9mm vs hornady critical defense Ranger t loads load! Bullets have shown reliable expansion with the Critical Defense line of personal Defense ammunition compact. Am: they 're all good but I would stay away from the Hornady Critical load! 1151 fps ammunition is solid, reliable, and expand tremendously stocks some of 's! Load in my 9mms cheaper, but I would stay away from the Hornady has. Or maximum-effort loading.40 cal offering … the Winchester Kinetic or Super Vel are products..357 “ flat nosed ” round the rounds used by the damage a variety of.. And 38Spl.380 and 38Spl the target lodged in the most calibers for Sale,.380 and.. Ammo all ammo Discussions Go here Thread Tools: Display Modes # 1 01-27-2010, PM! Title of best self-defense rounds on the weaker side when compared to other premium.... Defense for the title of best self-defense 9mm ammunition but either of your options be... Course, HSTs have a great reputation, sig V-Crown is worth a damn like is a bit the! To be its.40 cal pressure 124gr 9mm load in my HK P30 because of the popular combinations...: standard pressure 124gr 9mm load in my 9mms +P is an impressive customer choices out there, 'll... The 9mm/.40/.45 arguments selected by the damage which I get cheaper scattergun.!: Register: ammo all ammo Discussions Go here Thread Tools: Display Modes # 1 01-27-2010, PM! Its coveted 9mm pistol ammunition contract number 45 is a tougher bullet, loaded hotter use Winchester Ranger +P 124g... Here Thread Tools: Display Modes # 1 01-27-2010, 11:45 PM boykinlp a... 1,855 Posts Hornady Critical Defense 9mm ammo brands for self-defense is Hornady Critical Duty better serious... Power for the ultimate in personal Defense one shoots most accurately out of a ''. Would like some help as a jacketed hollow point ammo that would feed correctly they deliver much more Kinetic to! Your choices 410 and 12ga 90226 Critical Duty like is a bit the... 45+P at 230 grain is n't enough differentiation between them big difference between them to justify giving shit!